Pelotonvs Echelon vs NordicTrack – Which bike performs better?

0
36
Pelotonvs Echelon vs NordicTrack

These are the top three bike manufacturers that have been making waves with their awesome interactive bike models. Which of the three is the best in performance?

My name is Chrisand I am a big fan of indoor cycling. I’ve never been one to go out cycling in public so when the spinning classes and stationary bikes turned more interactive, I got sucked in to the glory of it all.

I have spent tons of hours researching and riding different bike types and brands and this gives me the knowledge to spot unique traits that each bike features regardless of how similar in appearance they are.

Peloton, Echelon and NordicTrack bikes have some similarities but they are not as many as their differences. Read on to see how these bikes differ in technical specifications, features and accessories to help guide your decision on which bike performs best.


What’s the difference between the Peloton, Echelon and NordicTrack?

 
Peloton
Echelon
NordicTrack
Handlebars 
Movable
Movable
Movable and control resistance
Pedals
Clip-in design – cycling shoes
Toe-cage design- sports shoes
Toe-cage design- sports shoes
Flywheel
30 pounds
29 pounds
32 pounds
Resistance
Magnetic with up to 100 levels
Magnetic with 32 levels
Magnetic with 24 levels
Weight Supported
297 lbs
300 lbs
350 lbs
Training App
Peloton
Echelon Fit
IFit
Screen
22-inch LED
21.5-inch HD
22-inch HD with inbuilt fan
Price
Check Here

 


Peloton vs Echelon vs NordicTrack – How do they compare?

Design

All three bikes are built of corrosion resistant steel which guarantees you a lifetime of use. NordicTrack’s flywheel is 32 pounds, Echelon carries a flywheel weighing 29 pounds and Peloton’s weighs 30 pounds which is not much of a difference.

The pedals are quite similar for all bikes.Echelon and NordicTrack’s pedals are easily set up with two-way pedals meaning you can either use the side with the toe-cage or, if you prefer to, you may opt to flip the pedal to ride on the flat surface like on an outdoor bike.

Peloton spots special pedals with three clip-ins on them meaning that you must incur an extra cost of buying cycling shoes with three cleats to clip-in to the pedals for a secure footing. With the other two, any sports shoe will do.

The pedals on all these bikes could be swapped for other alternatives if you have a specific type of pedals that you like to cycle on. Peloton supports a weight up to 297 pounds, Echelon stands at 300 pounds while NordicTrack can hold up to 350 pounds.

In terms of design and their efficiency, the NordicTrack and Echelon bikes have a leg up over Peloton because they have versatile pedals that do not require special cycling shoes to ride as compared to the Peloton which requires cycling shoes with cleats to clip-in to its pedals.

Comfort

Both Peloton and NordicTrack bikes feature a 22-inch screen that displays vital information and help the user connect with the virtual trainers and spinning classes available. Both bikes feature a camera attached to the screen with speakers at the back.

Echelon bikes on the other hand stand out from the crowd with their 21.5-inch screen that features other training workouts beside cycling like yoga, Pilates and weight training with the dumbbells.

Anti-grip handle bars and seats on all three bikes are easily and conveniently adjustable adding to the riding comfort.

NordicTrack has the added benefit of a cooling fan in-built in the console which is something that Echelon and Peloton lacks. Other than that, they are all very comfortable bikes to cycle on.

Functionality

All three bikes use a magnetic flywheel resistance. However, the resistance on the NordicTrack can be automatically controlled based on your cycling intensity by using the button controls on your handlebar. Peloton and Echelon bikes have a control knob on the bike’s frame for manual adjustments.

Their differently weighted flywheels do not give much difference in performance but Peloton has 100 levels of adjustable resistance which is sure to keep even the most experienced cyclist on toes. Echelon and NordicTrack provide users with 3-pound dumbbells but you need to purchase them for Peloton.

In performance, Echelon has beaten both Peloton and NordicTrack bikes because its screen can be flipped 180 degrees giving the user a chance to get off the bike and compliment their cycling with other workouts.


Peloton vs Echelon vs NordicTrack – A Comparison Overview

Peloton – Overview

This bike’s 32-pound wheel runs on magnetic resistance with 100 levels to adjust to. This adjustment is done manually or through the touchscreen.

The pedals on this bike may be problematic and present an extra cost to anyone who does not already own a pair of cycling shoes because they use the clip-in mechanism. This is ideal because with a securely locked in footing, you can then pull up in the cycling motion much easier which is great for glutes and hamstrings.

Peloton bike is fixed and does not move meaning there is no chance to incline or decline the bike for a more exciting cycling experience.

Pros

  • Ergonomic handlebars
  • Light in weight
  • Comfortable seat
  • Engaging App with live classes
  • Can sync with Bluetooth

Cons

  • Adjustment knob not accurate
  • No incline or decline
  • Adjustments done manually
  • Doesn’t give you weights
  • Needs new training shoes with 3 cleats or Replace pedals
  • Need to buy a heart rate monitor which has a problem pairing

View price on Amazon

Echelon EX5S – Overview

Echelon Connect EX5-S
  • 14 DAY TRIAL INCLUDED. The Echelon Fit APP provides totally immersive fitness in the comfort and convenience of your own home. Access to Live, On Demand classes, Scenic rides, Yoga, Stretching, and a host of additional classes using with your trainer of...
  • PEDAL YOUR WAY TO NEW HEIGHTS: The all new Connect EX5S has all the great features of the original Connect bike with new advanced technologies. New and improved stabilization handles and seat post adjustments including a competition seat with 6'...

This bike rides on a magnetic resistance mechanism to push a 29-pound flywheel with 32 levels of adjustable resistance.

Pedals are both compatible with SPD shoes and they are designed to flip over to the other side which is fitted with toe cages to secure any size footing.

Unique to the EX5S is its provision of a touchscreen holder that can swivel 180 degrees and is filled with more workouts other than cycling. By getting of the bike and flipping the screen, you can proceed to try out other workout techniques such as yoga meditation and Zumba.

Pros

  • 180 degrees flip touchscreen
  • Durable steel frame build
  • Compact and transportable
  • Magnetic resistance with 32 adjustable levels
  • 29-pound flywheel
  • Handlebars of Aero system provide great movement
  • Statics visible while training even without subscription
  • Pedals are SPD compatible and fully adjustable

Cons

  • Limited Functions with the Echelon Fit subscriptions
  • No other apps are compatible other than Echelon Fit

View price on Amazon

NordicTrack S22i – Overview

Nordictrack Commercial S22i Studio Cycle
  • Interactive personal training at home powered by iFit; 1-year iFit membership included with your exercise bike; Gain access to on-demand, interactive trainer-led global and studio workout programs ($396 value)
  • 22 inches interactive HD touchscreen display streams on-demand iFit workouts directly to your equipment and provides easy stats tracking; Adjustable display mount allows for 360-degree screen rotation

A Steel metal build with handle bars that are not only anti-grip but also have a coating that is sweat resistant.

Virtual training on this bike is made easy because the 24 resistance levels are digitally preset and can be controlled by the buttons on the handle bar or through the touchscreen. Because programs are preloaded, the bike automatically adjusts to whichever program you are on currently and is able to take you on scenic drives virtually anywhere in the world.

The pedals on this bike require no special cycling shoe because they have toe cages. This bike allows for 20% incline and 10% decline which enhances your experience.

Pros

  • More features than Peloton but more affordable
  • Supports 350 pounds
  • Toe cage with reversible flat pedal
  • Doesn’t need special cycling shoes
  • Swap out pedals on the bike optional
  • 3-pound weights provided
  • Heart rate monitor provided
  • Digital resistance is on handlebars with 24 levels
  • S22i has a knob that can stop the flywheel

Cons

  • Bike frame a little heavy
  • No Bluetooth Sync

View price on Amazon


Verdict and Conclusion: So, which between the Peloton, Echelon and NordicTrack Bikes performs the best?

Echelonbikes, in my opinion, have the best performance in resistance and versatility. For a home gym bike to include more than just cycling programs, be usable with any sports shoe and have an automatically adjustable magnetic resistance, it is a total package deal.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here